Graeme Smith is not convinced Virat Kohli should remain captain on a long-term basis and thinks India might benefit from having a "better leader".
Kohli has continued to set high standards with the bat, but snappily defended his captaincy when questioned were asked after the tourists slumped to a Test series defeat in South Africa.
The prolific skipper was fined for an outburst at umpire Michael Gough during the second Test at Centurion and criticised his fellow batsmen following defeat in that match.
Former Proteas captain Smith thinks Kohli needs to improve his leadership skills if he is to stay on in the role.
"I don't know, when I look at him, if he is a long-term captaincy option for India," Smith said at a SuperSport breakfast event.
"At the end of this year, he'd have been away from home for a while, the pressure he'll face, the scrutiny from the press - I know he only gets that in India - but if you're away from home and you're struggling for form as a team, I don't know if I'd want to burden Virat Kohli with that. Or if India have a better leader in that environment."
Smith feels Kohli finds it difficult to put himself in his team-mates' shoes.
"You can be the best player in the world, and you love that intensity and you often don't think what your team-mates are going through," Smith said.
"Sometimes you talk to AB de Villiers, he gets down and reverse sweeps, he makes it look so easy, and sometimes you need to remind AB that other guys don't see it that way.
"As a leader you need to understand the whole environment, talk to the players to try to get the best out of the environment. He might grow as he learns to soften that a little bit.
"His performances speak for themselves, it's about whether he can get the best out of those around him when they are under pressure."
|Kuzma leads USA past Team World|
|Thiem into semis in Buenos Aires, Isner cruises in New York|
|This can´t happen at Liverpool – Kovac warns Bayern over defensive errors|
|Thomas, Scott lead Genesis Open|
|Koulibaly pleased with transfer interest, but happy at Napoli|
|Allegri: Juventus must score in Madrid|
|Kuchar addresses criticism, apologises for paying fill-in caddie $5k|
|Life is for warriors – Neymar defiant as injury recovery continues|
|Neuer: Bayern Munich must cut out defensive ´madness´|
|Kovac: Bayern had Liverpool on the mind against Augsburg|
|Wawrinka and Nishikori to meet in Rotterdam semi-finals|
|Gloucester down leaders Exeter, Wasps beat Bristol|
|McCloskey marks landmark with try in Ulster win, Munster run riot|
|Allegri hails Dybala after Juventus star ends goal drought|
|Kovac fearful over fresh Coman ankle injury|
|Mahrez incredible in training - Guardiola takes blame for star´s exile|
|Depay can be among world´s best – Rafael|
|Wood ´felt like a superhero´ in devastating match-winning spell|
|QPR 0 Watford 1: Capoue strike secures quarter-final berth|
|Kaepernick v the NFL: How we got here|
|Juventus 3 Frosinone 0: Ronaldo rounds off routine romp|
|Augsburg 2 Bayern Munich 3: Classy Coman shines in comeback win|
|Ndombele draws Pogba comparisons from Lyon coach Genesio|
|Coady and Doherty pen new deals with Wolves|
|Kaepernick and Reid reach settlement in NFL collusion case|
|Neuer back in Bayern team after thumb injury|
|Giggs, Scholes and Beckham met Ferguson´s standards because of Harrison – ´Class of ´92´ graduate Ca|
|Mertens upsets Kerber to set up Halep Doha decider|
|Valverde: Barcelona scared? We´re top of LaLiga!|
|North and South Korea want to co-host 2032 Olympics|
|Zaha appeal against ban dismissed|
|Chisora to work with Bellew´s former coach Coldwell|
|Valverde still unsure on Umtiti return date ahead of Lyon tie|
|Hudson-Odoi getting enough Chelsea chances, insists Zola|
|Sexton back in full Ireland training|
|Chelsea, Malmo facing UEFA charges|
|Magnificent Halep storms back to reach Qatar Open final|
|No nerves for Ferrari new boy Leclerc|
|Solskjaer´s Manchester United impact has been remarkable - Zola|
|Valverde delighted by extra responsibility of new Barcelona contract|
|Martial and Lingard injuries open the door to Gomes and Chong – Solskjaer|
|Semenya backed by South African government in IAAF challenge|
|Proteas collapse gives Sri Lanka hope in Durban|
|Wales star Halfpenny misses Scarlets match|
|Guardiola: Wigan a warning to Manchester City for Newport trip|
|Martial, Lingard out for up to three weeks|
|Milan will need helmets against Atalanta - Gattuso|
|Suso ´deserves Milan renewal´ amid Spurs & Arsenal links|
|Tuchel avoids touchline ban from FFF|
|Christian crushes Sixers to set up all-Melbourne final|
|Newport star Amond hopes glasses are raised after Otamendi reunion|
|Aaron Smith try snatches win over Chiefs for 14-man Highlanders|
|A-League Review: Melbourne City drop points again as Newcastle Jets close on top six|
|Pieters pegged back by late bogey in Perth|
|Stability, a thriving Messi and success despite poor recruitment – Why Barca are keeping Valverde|
|Jenkins unperturbed by Jones´ Wales dig|
|Pogba wasn´t happy – Rafael applauds Solskjaer´s impact on Man United players|
|Turn the stump mics up! - Moeen wants sledging televised|
|Valverde signs one-year extension at Barcelona|
|Klopp almost became Bayern coach – Hoeness|
|Barkley to Davis: Don´t ruin your reputation as one of the nicest guys in the world|
|Westbrook extends triple-double streak in Thunder´s loss to Pelicans|
|Llorente ´very satisfied´ at Tottenham|
|Dodgers´ Bellinger: Even when I´m not good, I´m still really good|
|Harvick, Logano win Can-Am Duels|
|Pelicans star Davis suffers shoulder injury|
|Thiem stays perfect in Buenos Aires, Ferrer exits|
|Spieth tied for lead at rain-hit Genesis Open|
|´Special´ Son is one of Premier League´s best, says Vertonghen|
|Team LeBron v Team Giannis by the numbers|