Atletico Madrid missed the opportunity to go top of LaLiga as Mario Gaspar's strike secured a 1-1 draw for Villarreal at the Estadio de la Ceramica.
After a sluggish start to the season, which saw Atletico win just one of their opening four games, Diego Simeone's side had given themselves a glorious chance of reaching the league's summit on Saturday with three wins in their four previous outings.
Filipe Luis looked to have set them on their way to another victory, heading in after 51 minutes on a day where rivals Real Madrid continued their slump with a loss to Levante, but Mario's deflected effort 14 minutes later earned Javi Calleja's side a deserved point.
Villarreal could have even gone on to win the game, but were kept at bay by some superb goalkeeping from Jan Oblak, while Atletico had their chance to win it when Thomas Lemar somehow headed Juanfran's cross wide with a minute remaining.
The closest either side came during a tepid opening half-hour was Antoine Griezmann's dipping effort from 25 yards, which flashed just over Sergio Asenjo's crossbar.
Oblak had to be alert soon after to tip over Jaume Costa's deflected strike and preserve his side’s status as the only team in Europe's top five leagues not to concede a first-half goal this season.
The visitors forged ahead after the restart when Griezmann's inswinging free-kick was headed against his own crossbar by Ramiro Funes Mori and Filipe nodded in the rebound from 10 yards.
They were pegged back after 65 minutes, however, when Mario's low strike was deflected past Oblak by Filipe after a goalmouth scramble.
The goalkeeper had to be at his very best to push away Pablo Fornals' drive soon after and then thwart the clean-through Carlos Bacca to ensure his side at least left with a point.
Atletico almost claimed victory with Lemar's late chance, but an end-to-end finish did not produce a winner.
What does it mean: Missed opportunity for Atleti
Their time at the summit could have been a short one given that a Barcelona or Sevilla win in their match later on Saturday would have dethroned them, but it would still have been quite the achievement after their poor start to the campaign, and a chance to capitalise on the chaos at Santiago Bernabeu.
A draw was no disgrace, though, and stretched their unbeaten run in the league to six games. Villarreal, meanwhile, will be buoyed by their stirring second-half display and should get back to winning ways soon if they continue to play like that.
Oblak in inspired form
Oblak sat out of Slovenia's games during the international break, and it proved to be a wise move with a superb performance to deny Villarreal. He was immense in the second half and was only beaten for the equaliser by a cruel deflection, ending the match with five saves.
Griezmann out of sorts
He scored twice in France's win over Germany in midweek, but Atleti's talismanic forward was way short of his best on Saturday. Griezmann's free-kick led to the Filipe goal, but in open play he was comfortably kept at arm's length by the Villarreal backline, and he only had one shot all game - typical of a poor attacking display from his side.
Key Opta stats: Simeone cannot solve Villarreal puzzle
- Atletico have failed to win their last seven LaLiga games against Villarreal (D3 L4), their second-worst active run against a single opponent (Barcelona - 16).
- Filipe scored his very first headed goal in LaLiga (14 goals in 332 appearances).
- Villarreal have failed to win each of their last six home league matches (D3 L3), equalling their worst streak at home in the top flight recorded in October 2003 (D5 L1).
- This is the first Villarreal season that they failed to win any of their first five LaLiga home games (D2 L3).
- Oblak has saved 14 of the last 15 shots on target he has faced in LaLiga.
Atleti resume their Champions League campaign on Wednesday with a visit to Bundesliga leaders Borussia Dortmund, while Villarreal host Rapid Vienna a day later in the Europa League before a Saturday league trip to high-flying Deportivo Alaves.
|Maiden winner Pan claims RBC Heritage as Johnson capitulates|
|We cannot influence Manchester derby, neither can United – Klopp trolls Solskjaer´s men|
|Stevens proud of Celtics for keeping foot on the accelerator to sweep Pacers|
|DeRozan fined $25k for throwing ball at referee|
|Garcia and Mladenovic put past feud behind them to send France into Fed Cup final|
|I am sure to stay at PSG – Mbappe insists he is not Real Madrid-bound|
|Special Foden has something that´s difficult to find – Guardiola|
|Sarri: Chelsea´s League Cup run on par with Tottenham´s heroics|
|Munster condemn pitch invader who confronted Vunipola|
|NHL awards 2019: Brent Burns, Mark Giordano, Victor Hedman named Norris Trophy finalists|
|Paris Saint-Germain 3 Monaco 1: Mbappe leads title celebrations with hat-trick as Neymar returns|
|Celtics sweep Pacers to advance to semi-finals|
|Neymar makes return from injury as substitute against Monaco|
|Words mean little – De Gea apologetic for disastrous Manchester United performance|
|PSG in Notre Dame jersey tribute against Monaco|
|Benzema the world´s best striker – Zidane|
|Patel the hero as Challengers survive Dhoni´s devastating display|
|Injured PAOK captain comes off bench to celebrate club´s first title in 34 years|
|It is in our hands – Emery confident on Arsenal´s Champions League hopes|
|Liverpool prove to be a cut above Cardiff thanks to Klopp´s pitch-perfect plan|
|Neymar back on the bench for PSG´s clash with Monaco|
|Ringrose: ´Incredible´ Saracens awaiting Leinster in final|
|Hodgson prepared to fight to keep Zaha at Crystal Palace|
|All we can do is keep the pressure on Man City, admits Milner|
|This is my home – Marcelo wants Real Madrid stay|
|Cardiff City 0 Liverpool 2: Resilient Reds return to the Premier League summit|
|Arsenal 2 Crystal Palace 3: Zaha on target as Gunners slip up in top four race|
|Solskjaer: I´ll be successful at Man United... some of these players won´t be|
|Man United were rancid – Neville furious after ´embarrassing´ Everton defeat|
|Silva: Everton better team from first minute|
|Leinster set up Saracens showdown after proving too strong for Toulouse|
|Real Madrid 3 Athletic Bilbao 0: Hat-trick hero Benzema scores for fifth game in a row to seal victo|
|Damned United? The astounding stats as Red Devils hit 38-year low at Everton|
|Everything went wrong – Solskjaer apologises for Man Utd´s Everton horror show|
|Freiburg 0 Borussia Dortmund 4: BVB keep pace with Bayern|
|Paris Saint-Germain 2018-19: Mbappe´s continued rise shows Neymar is now disposable|
|Fognini follows up Nadal win by clinching first Masters title|
|Paris Saint-Germain 2018-19: How dominant title win compares to previous QSI years|
|BREAKING NEWS: PSG retain Ligue 1 title thanks to Lille draw|
|Everton 4 Manchester United 0: Toffees score biggest Premier League win over sorry Red Devils|
|Warner and Bairstow dominate again as Sunrisers thrash KKR|
|Colts owner Jim Irsay buys John Lennon´s ´Sgt. Pepper´ piano|
|People are having a free shot - Seibold defends young Broncos|
|Zidane must make Real Madrid hungry again - Seedorf|
|Young dropped as Solskjaer makes three changes for Everton clash|
|Lemar hopeful Griezmann stays at Atletico|
|Khan refutes Crawford´s accusations of quitting after low blow|
|Deciding doubles triumph sends Australia into Fed Cup final|
|Pakistan call up Yasir with Shadab laid low by virus|
|Wellington Phoenix 3 Melbourne City 2: Krishna´s last-gasp hat-trick boosts top-four hopes|
|Oh, for real? I didn´t know! - Harden unaware of early shooting woes|
|Solskjaer warns Alexis Sanchez Man Utd won´t carry players|
|Dele Alli thinks Tottenham´s Champions League run has Russian roots|
|Leilua brace downs Broncos as Raiders keep pace at NRL summit|
|Spalletti hails Inter´s Roma draw as ´precious´|
|Stuttgart had to make Weinzierl decision - Hitzlsperger|
|Tucker´s homer on MLB debut powers Pirates to fifth straight win|
|76ers win thriller, Rockets overcome Harden struggles to move 3-0 ahead|
|Crawford retains title by TKO after low blow stops Khan|
|MLS Review: De Boer´s Atlanta woes continue, Nani lifts Orlando|
|Garcia beats Granados via seventh-round TKO|
|Muller: Bayern feeling title pressure|
|He parks the bus right in front of De Gea – Van Gaal critical of Solskjaer again|
|Red Sox star Eovaldi on injured list with elbow issue|
|We real cool – Lillard plays down Westbrook feud|
|Embiid trolls Warriors after 76ers take 3-1 lead over Nets|
|Allegri dismisses criticism after Scudetto success|
|Solskjaer warns of no quick-fix for Man United in transfer market|
|Klopp a hermit amid Liverpool title hype|
|Dudley is ´a nobody´ – 76ers star Embiid|